| Time *ET | Matchup | Prediction | Actual | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1:05 PM |  Toronto Blue Jays @ New York Yankees  Sean Reid-Foley vs Luis Severino by 1.5 | New York Yankees win 6.3-4.0 by 2.3 | New York Yankees wins 11-6 |   |
| 4:05 PM |  Baltimore Orioles @ Cleveland Guardians  Alex Cobb vs Adam Plutko by 1.5 | Cleveland Guardians win 5.1-3.9 by 1.2 | Baltimore Orioles wins 4-2 |  |
| 4:05 PM |  Houston Astros @ Oakland Athletics  Dallas Keuchel vs Trevor Cahill by 1.5 | Houston Astros win 3.3-2.8 by 0.5 | Oakland Athletics wins 7-1 | |
| 4:05 PM |  New York Mets @ Philadelphia Phillies  Jacob deGrom vs Jake Arrieta by 1.5 | Philadelphia Phillies win 3.9-3.7 by 0.2 | New York Mets wins 3-1 | |
| 7:05 PM |  Chicago Cubs @ Pittsburgh Pirates  Tyler Chatwood vs Joe Musgrove by 1.5 | Pittsburgh Pirates win 3.8-3.8 by 0.0 | Pittsburgh Pirates wins 3-1 | |
| 7:05 PM |  Miami Marlins @ Washington Nationals  Wei-Yin Chen vs Jefry Rodriguez by 1.5 | Washington Nationals win 4.7-3.2 by 1.5 | Miami Marlins wins 7-5 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Colorado Rockies @ Atlanta Braves  Antonio Senzatela vs Mike Foltynewicz by 1.5 | Atlanta Braves win 3.8-3.5 by 0.3 | Colorado Rockies wins 5-3 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Detroit Tigers @ Minnesota Twins  Ryan Carpenter vs Kohl Stewart by 1.5 | Detroit Tigers win 5.0-3.7 by 1.3 | Detroit Tigers wins 7-5 |  |
| 7:10 PM |  Kansas City Royals @ Chicago White Sox  Brad Keller vs Dylan Covey by 1.5 | Kansas City Royals win 3.6-3.1 by 0.6 | Kansas City Royals wins 3-1 | |
| 7:10 PM |  San Francisco Giants @ Cincinnati Reds  Madison Bumgarner vs Matt Harvey by 1.5 | San Francisco Giants win 3.6-2.8 by 0.8 | Cincinnati Reds wins 7-1 | |
| 7:10 PM |  Tampa Bay Rays @ Boston Red Sox  Tyler Glasnow vs David Price by 1.5 | Tampa Bay Rays win 3.7-3.5 by 0.3 | Boston Red Sox wins 5-2 | |
| 7:15 PM |  Milwaukee Brewers @ St. Louis Cardinals  Wade Miley vs Miles Mikolas by 1.5 | Milwaukee Brewers win 3.1-2.7 by 0.4 | St. Louis Cardinals wins 7-2 | |
| 8:05 PM |  Los Angeles Angels @ Texas Rangers  Andrew Heaney vs Martin Perez by 1.5 | Los Angeles Angels win 7.7-4.3 by 3.4 | Los Angeles Angels wins 11-7 | |
| 8:40 PM |  Arizona Diamondbacks @ San Diego Padres  Zack Godley vs Clayton Richard by 1.5 | Arizona Diamondbacks win 3.6-3.2 by 0.4 | San Diego Padres wins 7-6 | |
| 10:10 PM |  Los Angeles Dodgers @ Seattle Mariners  Rich Hill vs Erasmo Ramirez by 1.5 | Los Angeles Dodgers win 6.0-3.2 by 2.8 | Seattle Mariners wins 5-4 | |
Legend/Totals
| Correct Picks | 5 (33.3%) |
| Incorrect Picks | 10 (66.7%) |
| Final Margin within 5 Pts | 2 (13.3%) |
| Beat the Spread | 11 (73.3%) |
